The Noble Justice Dhingra in action again. This time delivers justice in a HMA case, Parnab Kumar Chakarborthy Vs Ruma Chakarborthy-2008
Here is what he had to say:
- 3. The petitioner in his petition has stated that the learned Court has taken into account his gross salary while his net salary after deduction was hardly Rs.5,000/-. He had to maintain two houses. He was working in Bhiwadi in Rajasthan as Shift In charge, his daughter from the earlier deceased wife was living at his ancestral house at Rai Barelli with his ailing mother. Thus, he had to maintain two units; one at Rai Barelli and other at Rajasthan. He also pleaded that the learned ADJ had not taken into account the fact that the wife was a professional beautician, who had done diploma in beauty-culture and hair dressing and in the bio data supplied to him at the time of marriage, it was stated that she was a freelance beautician doing the work of beautician. He further stated that the account of expenditure given by the wife would show that she was living in luxury, which was not possible out of the meager income of her father, who was a retired Naval Officer and since she was qualified and was spending a lot so, there was a presumption that she was earning and she had not come to the Court with clean hands.
Here is the judgment:
Justice Dhingra Quashed An HMA Case-2008
_____________________________________________________________________
Many ladies in the country are accused of filing false, greedy and nasty cases with ulterior motives – but a lot of blame should also be shared by the lawyers of such ladies.
Unfortunately, lawyers operate in a manner that makes general public believe that lawyers community is a rogue community. A lot of lawyers take money and abuse the opponent party. They abuse the court process. Why not public think the way they think?
A lot of lawyers write filthy allegations, add lies thinking that it would strenthen their case, operate in a manner that causes inconvenience to the court and to the other party, mislead cases and what not.
I hope the Hon’ble judge Shiv Narayna Dhingra Sir passes a judgment that properly deals with the nasty conduct of the advocates.
LikeLike